Multani v. Witkin & Neal, Castle Green Condominium Association, etc.
By David Swedelson, Condo Lawyer and HOA Attorney, Partner at SwedelsonGottlieb, Community Association Attorneys
This right of redemption is unusual in that it does not apply to non-judicial foreclosure on trust deeds; it was added to the law for community associations several years ago to help owners so they do not lose their homes because they did not pay their associations’ assessments or fees. Owners rarely take advantage of this right. But that does not mean that the foreclosing association and, more specifically, the foreclosure trustee retained by the association do not need to give notice of this right. And this was confirmed in the recent Court of Appeal decision in the case of Multani v. Witkin & Neal.
Here are the facts (although I do suggest that the actual decision be read, as there were some interesting allegations, including the allegation that the condo association locked the owners out of their unit): In 2005, Afshan and Rahim Multani were informed by Castle Green Homeowners Association that they were delinquent in paying their homeowner assessment fees. From 2006 to 2008, the Association and the Multanis continued to dispute the alleged delinquency. The Multanis requested alternative dispute resolution after the Association set a sale date of the condominium for January 27, 2009, to which the Association allegedly did not respond. On July 23, 2009, the Association held its nonjudicial foreclosure sale. However, the Association and its trustee (Witkin & Neal, which despite the name is NOT a law firm) failed to notify the Multanis that the sale had been postponed; nor did they provide notice of the sale after the sale occurred or notice of the Multanis’ right to redeem their property.
On November 19, 2009, the Multanis received a courtesy copy of an unlawful detainer complaint notifying them of the sale. They filed their lawsuit against the Association, seeking to set aside the foreclosure proceedings, contending that despite having the correct address, the Association started sending notices to the wrong P.O. Box.
The trial court granted summary judgment for the Association, finding the Multanis had actual knowledge of the foreclosure, but failed to exercise their 90-day statutory right of redemption. The Court of Appeal disagreed and overturned the decision of the trial court.
The Court of Appeal made this decision based primarily on the failure of Witkin & Neal to give notice of the sale and the right of redemption. The Court held that while generally there is no postsale right of redemption in nonjudicial foreclosure proceedings, a nonjudicial foreclosure conducted by an association for delinquent assessments is subject to the right of redemption within 90 days after the sale. Under Code of Civil Procedure section 729.050, the trustee who conducts the sale must promptly serve notice of the right of redemption on the judgment debtor, which shall indicate the applicable redemption period. In this case, the Court found that the Association failed to provide any evidence that it or its trustee, Witkin & Neal, complied with this statutory requirement, and the Multanis did not receive notice from the trustee following the sale on July 23, 2009. It was on this basis that the Court of Appeal found that the trial court erred in granting the Association’s summary judgment.
Note: In full disclosure, SwedelsonGottlieb’s assessment collection affiliate Association Lien Services is a business competitor of Witkin & Neal. Association Lien Services makes it part of its procedures to give all required notices, including the notice of the foreclosure sale and the right of redemption.
Also, we disclose that several years ago we were legal counsel for the Castle Green Homeowners Association located in Pasadena. We assisted this Association in many matters, including the conversion from a beneficial trust that had been formed in or around 1930 when the Association was formed and converted to a community association from a hotel.
David Swedelson is a community association legal expert and senior and founding partner at SwedelsonGottlieb, and is a shareholder in the firm’s affiliate, Association Lien Services.